Fionnáin reviewed Practice by Gavin Van Horn (Kinship: Belonging In A World Of Relations, #5)
Diverse Opinions, Unclear Aims
3 stars
The final book in the 5-part series 'Kinship' is titled 'Practice'. The implication is that this volume will deal with how to practice kinship in real life scenarios. It comprises essays, articles and poems by different writers considering kinship from this angle. Like the other volumes, the focus is US-centric and the resultant contributions are a mixed bag. I really enjoyed some of the writing, particularly Trebbe Johnson's essay on coal and Alison Hawthorne Deming's poem about kinship with trees and crows. However, even these stronger works spoke little to the idea of 'practice', and other essays and writing seemed to miss the series' concepts altogether.
In the end the mixed bag is more miss than hit, and it was just an OK ending to a series of books that could have been so much better if they had been less volumes and more tightly edited. The result is an …
The final book in the 5-part series 'Kinship' is titled 'Practice'. The implication is that this volume will deal with how to practice kinship in real life scenarios. It comprises essays, articles and poems by different writers considering kinship from this angle. Like the other volumes, the focus is US-centric and the resultant contributions are a mixed bag. I really enjoyed some of the writing, particularly Trebbe Johnson's essay on coal and Alison Hawthorne Deming's poem about kinship with trees and crows. However, even these stronger works spoke little to the idea of 'practice', and other essays and writing seemed to miss the series' concepts altogether.
In the end the mixed bag is more miss than hit, and it was just an OK ending to a series of books that could have been so much better if they had been less volumes and more tightly edited. The result is an interesting failed experiment for me.